Defending the Modern Star Wars: Debunking Criticisms and Maintaining the Franchise

Star Wars, a beloved franchise, is currently undergoing a rebirth under Disney's ownership. However, this new era has not been without its share of criticism. One common complaint is that the introduction of a female protagonist is often cited as a reason for dislike. This essay seeks to address this issue and provide a balanced perspective on the modern Star Wars era.

The Misguided Gender Argument

It's often stated that the main reason for the perceived failures in recent Star Wars films has to be the gender of the main character. This is a peculiar assertion considering the prequels and the 'Solo' film also fared poorly, yet no one blamed them for having a male protagonist. This double standard is evident, and it rings hollow when the argument centers around a gender that is considered 'default.' Claiming that deviating from the default gender is proof of losing money is both narrow-minded and unfair.

Unsatisfactory Sequel Trilogy

The new trilogy is often criticized for not matching the beloved original trilogy. However, this sentiment can be traced back to a more fundamental issue: attachment to the original work. While some fans cannot accept changes, others find it easier to embrace new elements and fresh storytelling. The idea that the original trilogy is invulnerable to criticism is a common misconception. It is natural for any long-standing franchise to face criticism and evolve. The challenge lies in finding a balance between honoring the past and embracing the future.

Attracting New Audiences

Some critics argue that the new Star Wars films should cater exclusively to long-term fans, neglecting the need to attract new audiences. However, a good film should not just appease the current fanbase but also introduce new fans to the franchise. The 'Last Jedi' may have been divisive, but it undoubtedly made crucial decisions to keep Star Wars fresh and relevant. Change is necessary for any evolving franchise, just as BBC's 'Doctor Who' continually introduces new elements to attract and retain viewers.

The True Menace: Fan Over-Enthusiasm

While some fans discuss criticism maturely, others can become overly sensitive and overreact to small imperfections. This excessive reaction can prove detrimental to the franchise's longevity. It's important for fans to remain rational and constructive in their critique, remembering that it's just a film. The franchise's resilience lies in its ability to evolve and adapt to changing tastes and norms.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the modern Star Wars era is here to stay. The franchise is undergoing a renaissance, and with it, both challenges and opportunities. While criticism is inevitable, it is essential to approach it with a balanced perspective. The key to success lies in maintaining the core elements that made Star Wars a beloved franchise while also embracing change and innovation. The true threat to Star Wars is not external criticism but overzealous fan behavior. So, let's keep the discussions respectful and focused on improving the franchise, rather than tearing it down.