The Impact of Detention on Character Development: An Analysis of The Breakfast Club

Imagine if

If Bender or Any Other Character Skipped Detention

In the 1985 movie The Breakfast Club, it is clear that the characters' experiences and relationships are deeply influenced by their time spent in detention. Specifically, the movie explores how Bender and the other students develop a deeper understanding of each other through their interactions. What if one of them, such as Bender, had skipped detention or only left early without permission? This hypothetical scenario would significantly alter the dynamics and development of the characters.

Consequences on Detention Attendance

For those familiar with the consequences of skipping Saturday school, the penalties could be severe. Skipping detention, as a rule, often results in a 3-day suspension. Further infractions can lead to extended suspensions or even expulsion from school. Such severe penalties would certainly deter any character from daring to skip.

The Original Dynamic of The Breakfast Club

The dynamics of The Breakfast Club

Despite the strictness of Vernon, a theme that emerges is the growth and development of relationships among the characters. Bender and Claire, for instance, develop a relationship that transcends their initial hostility, partly due to their shared experience of detention. Without this shared experience, their unique connection would likely never have formed.

Alternative Scenarios

Imagine a version of the movie where characters like Bender skip their detention. In such a scenario, the club itself would become less meaningful. There would be no central group to discuss their individual problems and understand each other better. The essence of the movie, which revolves around characters learning about each other's backgrounds and personal struggles, would be diluted.

Historical Similarities: Groucho Marx’s Absence

It's fascinating to note that Groucho Marx, a prominent comedian, attended Shermer High School at the same time as Bender and the other students. Interestingly, Groucho also received a detention on that same Saturday. Despite the unfortunate overlap, Groucho never showed up for his detention. Legend has it that he spent his day at the races and attended the opera that night. His absence seems to have had a ripple effect; instead of being part of the movie he inspired, it led to John Hughes directing a different film where Groucho took over a high school and appointed his brothers as teachers in various subjects.

Conclusion: The Necessity of Detention Attendance

In conclusion, the presence of all characters at detention is not merely a plot device but a crucial element in the development of their individual character arcs and the overall narrative of the movie. As Vernon might institute even more severe punishments, the absence of key characters would significantly impact the story.

So, the reality is that if any character in the movie didn't show up for detention, there might not even be a movie. The shared experience and interactions within the Sunday detention room were the building blocks of the characters' growth and mutual understanding, all of which contribute to the meaningful and timeless nature of The Breakfast Club.