Why Did Wonder Woman 1984 Fail?

The release of Wonder Woman 1984 in 2020 marked a significant point both for the film industry and the life of the Wonder Woman franchise. Its release, however, was met with mixed reviews, financial underperformance, and a myriad of criticism and controversy. This article delves into the reasons behind its shortcomings and provides valuable insights for aspiring filmmakers.

Mixed Critical Reception

The release of Wonder Woman 1984 garnered a range of reviews from both critics and audiences. While the first part of the franchise received universal acclaim, the sequel failed to live up to the same level of success. Critics found the film to be a mixed bag, praising certain aspects but failing in others.

High Expectations

One of the key factors that contributed to the film's failure was the overwhelming hype and high expectations generated by the success of its predecessor, Wonder Woman (2017). Audiences and critics alike anticipated another stellar performance and visual spectacle. When 1984 did not meet these expectations, the first signs of disappointment became evident.

Pandemic Release

The release of 1984 coincided with the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. The global health crisis had significant repercussions on the film industry, affecting audience behavior, box office performance, and overall consumer confidence. The pandemic led to the closure of many theaters, reduced operating capacity, and audience hesitance to return to the cinema. These factors severely limited the film's potential box office revenue.

Confusing Plot and Tone

Critics pointed out that the film's narrative was convoluted and its tone shifted inconsistently, resulting in a less engaging viewing experience. Unlike the first film, which had a straightforward narrative, 1984 was criticized for its complex story and inconsistent pacing. This was further exacerbated by the film's ambiguous relationships and dramatic developments that seemed disconnected from the first part of the franchise.

Timing and Competition

Another factor that contributed to 1984's underperformance was the release timing and competition from other films. The release coincided with a period when other high-profile films were also in theaters, splitting audience attention. Additionally, the changing landscape of film consumption saw many viewers opt for streaming services over theatrical releases, further diluting 1984's box office potential.

Writer and Director Mismatch

The transition from a well-loved film like the first Wonder Woman to a sequel directed by Patty Jenkins, a talented director but not a seasoned writer, highlighted the challenges of adapting from one genre to another. While Patty Jenkins demonstrated her prowess as a director, her writing skills were not up to par for a significant part of 1984. The film was seen as overly simplistic and catering to a younger audience, lacking the depth and complexity necessary to sustain a larger, more mature audience.

Review Critique

The critic's viewpoint on 1984 was particularly harsh, pointing out the film's preachiness and lack of depth. Instead of delivering a nuanced and character-driven narrative, the movie was described as a simplification, relying on clichés and simplistic storytelling. The reviewer also criticized the film for its predictable plot and character choices, with particular emphasis on the portrayal of Kristen Wiig, who was not well-received. Wiig's performance was seen as outdated and failing to contribute positively to the overall narrative. The decision to involve her in a role that did not align with the narrative expectations of the franchise was seen as a misstep.

Lessons for Future Filmmakers

The failure of 1984 serves as a cautionary tale for aspiring filmmakers and industry stakeholders. It underscores the importance of balancing narrative complexity, character development, and audience expectations with the right balance of direction and writing. Understanding the landscape of film consumption and adapting to changing viewer behaviors is also crucial. The film's mixed reception reminds us of the value of listening to feedback and continuously refining our craft.